Skip to main content

WHY IS THE EUCHARIST RESERVED FOR CATHOLICS ONLY?

Time flies! On the 25th of March, three months had passed since Christmas 2022. Also, this marked the celebration of the Annunciation of the Angel to Mary precisely nine months before Christmas 2023. Lent is now almost over as we enter the Last Supper, followed by the sorrow of Good Friday and end with the joy of Easter Sunday celebrating the resurrection of Jesus. 

Scuola Grande di San Rocco Museum, Venice

Lent prepares us to recall where the Mass began and not something a random Catholic thought up for dramatic effect. Let's go back about 1990 years ago to the year 33. It was in a large upper room filled with twelve apostles with all their eyes fixed on Jesus at the centre of the table. There he sat and taught his apostles their final lesson before he prepared for His death. The room was probably prepared with light and filled with the aroma of wild herbs, salt water, unleavened bread, wine, and the meat of the sacrificial lamb. Why this special occasion? The Jews were celebrating the Passover. 

The Passover celebrated the Jews' freedom from slavery in Egypt. The Passover celebrated that God spared the life of every firstborn son by instructing the angel of death to not take the life of those who marked their doorpost with the blood of a sacrificial lamb. Why is this relevant to us? The Old Testament was preparing us for something profound. On another occasion, God asked Abraham to take his son's life on the mountain as an act of love for God. Before Abraham was about to do the unthinkable, God spared his son's life. God had been preparing us to understand how much He truly loves us, that He would allow this time His only Son to take the place of the sacrificial lamb. Instead of staining the doorpost with blood, he stained the post of the cross on Calvary with His very own blood to save all humanity from the eternal punishment of sin. 

All these symbolisms come to life at the Last Supper (the very first Mass). In the upper room, the night before Jesus died, He performed the greatest miracle by bringing the animation of the Passover to life. That night Our Lord instituted the Mass. It remains a miracle that occurs every day worldwide by every priest who celebrates the Mass and remains the greatest mystery by bringing us the living Body and Blood of Jesus Christ in the substance of unleavened bread and wine. Does it sound a little unreal? Well, it should, as this defies our own human understanding, science and the mere concept of time itself. 

Jesus sat with his apostles and said, "I have earnestly desired to eat this Passover with you before I suffer, for I tell you I shall not eat it until it is fulfilled in the kingdom of God" (Luke 22:15-16). The night before this happened, twelve apostles were invited to the Last Supper. One of them chose to not believe, but the remaining eleven were given the grace to consecrate the ordinary substance of bread and wine from that day forward in the Mass into His Body and Blood. This consecration is integrally linked to the redemption and suffering on Calvary. So every time the Mass is celebrated by a priest, it is the unbloody reenactment of Our Lord's suffering and redemption on the cross that comes to life on the altar. 

This is why the Eucharist is reserved for Catholics who believe that Jesus is consecrated on the altar and remains present to us. The mystery enables us to unite our sufferings, prayers and offerings with Jesus in the Mass. In other words, I can offer my prayers, joys and challenges in my daily work, suffering in the day for someone close to me or acts of thanksgiving every day and take it to the altar. At the altar, I place it there spiritually, and Our Lord unites our earthly suffering with his eternal redemption for our sake and for those with whom we pray. 

So why is the Eucharist reserved for Catholics? If, as Christians, we do not believe in the real presence of Our Lord in the Eucharist, we might take for granted Our Lord's tender body which we consume. It would be like disregarding an important guest of honour as unimportant. A more concrete example (said with the utmost respect) is if we believe that anyone can stand before believers and repeat the words of scripture, "Take, eat; this is my body" (Matthew 26:26) over crackers and juice, we risk blaspheming Jesus who is made present in the Mass.

This is where Catholics can seem they belong to some exclusive club. Definitely not! Why is it not the same thing? I answer the question by posing another question. Can the pastor who repeats words from Matthew's gospel over cracker bread and grape juice be traced back to an unbroken line with the first apostles? In other words, did he receive the laying on of hands directly from Jesus, who lay His hands on Peter, and Peter on his successor and so forth up to Pope Francis? Any priest in the Catholic Church who consecrates unleavened bread and wine was consecrated a priest by a bishop who was consecrated a bishop by the Pope. Every Pope over the past two millennia had received the laying of hands, starting with Peter when Jesus entrusted the Church to him.

Our Lord, after his resurrection, instructed Peter to "feed my sheep" (John 21:15-17), meaning he gave Peter the keys to govern the house of God, the Church. Well, on another occasion, he gave the apostles the power to "bind and loose" (Matthews 18:18), meaning they had the authority to absolve sins, pronounce doctrinal judgements, and make decisions in the Church (CCC, 553). 

For about 1,521 years, all Christians were Catholic (which means universal). There was no distinction, and we all believed the same thing. Martin Luther, who started out nobly by wanting to correct the misuse of resources in the Church at the time, broke with wisdom that had been accumulated over the last 1,500. He "protested" against the core teachings and broke with the universality and created his own church that believed some things and lost others. Most significantly, he lost the Eucharist, the central belief. 

Up to 2023, his split had resulted in more than 45,000 different Christian denominations worldwide (undoubtedly, that is not what Our Lord wanted when he died for us on the cross?!). Only one of those 45,000 "denominations" believes and holds true to where and how the Church all began. The Protestant (coming from protest) bible was edited and replaced with what Lutherans considered necessary. Unfortunately, this division means many Christians have forgotten about history out of no fault of their own for the last 500 years.

Sadly, this break has separated many Christians with good intentions from the real presence of the sacraments that ultimately point us to the Eucharist (the summit of our faith) and where we truly encounter the living Body of our Lord Jesus Christ. 

Wishing you and your families a Blessed Easter as we await the Risen Lord.


Do you know of a friend who could be interested in reading this blog? Please feel free to share the link.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

WHAT DOES IT MEAN TO BE OPEN TO LIFE?

I received a gift of this plant from my friends, Alex and Thato probably about five years ago. It was originally two succulents in a small boot pot. Over the years it started producing new shoots so I transferred it to a bonsai training pot. I put this training pot next to my desk and one day I ate an apple took some of the seeds pushed it into the pot and honestly forgot about it. At the end of November, I saw three little shoots sprouting and realised the apple seeds had taken. Two of the sprouts were growing nicely until...   Apple seed sprouts, 9 December 2024 First, let me start by saying this blog will be very personal and intimate but this sprouting of seed is a testament to something the world has neglected in the past 60 years or so and this parable is very telling. If you search global fertility rates by country you find a marked decline from around the 1960s when the data was first collected to now. In the 1960s the average number of children per woman was around 5 ...

From the rising of the sun to its setting: we find the meaning of life

A few months ago we went away for the weekend to a little resort nestled in a ravine in Limpopo. It was the tail end of winter and so the chill of the early morning would bite, but this also meant watching the sun rise over the mountain, slowly pierce through the trees, stretching the first rays of the morning sun through the thick of the bush that had been in complete darkness through the night. Bela Bela, 07:17 - 26 July 2025 This made for prayer inspired by the treasure of nature, free of the distractions and hustle of city life. The sight of the sun sparked the words of the Mass in the common Eucharistic prayer, which quotes Psalm 113:3: "From the rising of the sun to its setting the name of the LORD is to be praised!" The sun rises and sets day after day without fail. As I sat there, I realised how small I was in the universe, a tiny insignificant dot at the tip of Africa in some random bush. However, at the same time, I felt so loved that in the immensity of the univers...

DEATH, A DOOR TO LIFE

I recently wrote about grandparents as humanities living memory and detailed how I had three grandparents still alive. A month later, my grandmother (Maria De Menezes) passed away, and six days later, my grandfather (Reginald Joel) passed on.  14 June 2021, God's Window Mpumalanga Death is a strange thing and most unnatural to human beings as it leaves us feeling empty, confused, and maybe afraid of what might await us on the other side. The most apparent question death makes us ponder is the question of why? Why must we die? Does God enjoy punishing us with the void the death of a loved one can leave in our hearts? The answer is a profound no!  Before sin entered the world, there was harmony between the body and soul. However, when the first man and woman chose to give in to the devil's temptation and succumbed to his luring. The nature of sin that entered the world broke this harmony. When sin enters the world by our free but misdirected choices, we allow corruption to weake...

TOB PART I - WHO ARE WE?

We took our boys for their first glamping trip with their grandparents (my parents) to a resort in Limpopo called Klein Kariba. It had been about 18 years since I last visited the resort and a lot had changed. It is a little over an hour outside of the city of Pretoria and nestled in a beautiful valley.  Noah & Leo feeding Njala, 23 April 2024 One late afternoon as we prepared to make a fire a group of Njala (a lesser Kudu according to Google I won't pretend to know my antelope haha) came past to graze on nearby trees. Noah and Leo were able to feed them leaves and even stroke them. Raphael even got up close and giggled in baby talk as the female Njala was intrigued by a little baby. It is not common to get so close to wild antelope and the young herd may have recalled people feeding them leaves from the tree tops they couldn't reach when they were young. This exchange with creation can beg the question of, "Who are we?" and what makes us so different to the anima...

DEAR BABY JESUS

It is already December; looking back, 2023 has flashed past in record time. The end of the year brings a big joy as we end the calendar year with the Advent season, which prepares us for the anticipation of the coming of Baby Jesus. This Christmas, I want to write about a letter that was found from Pope Benedict XVI's (the then Joseph Ratzinger) childhood.  @Pope_news, Twitter The young Pope referred to Our Lord as "Baby Jesus" and asked for two spiritual gifts in his letter and received them quite literally later on in his life. I had to search what this "green chasuble" is, and it is a priestly vestment worn to celebrate the Eucharist. In other words, he was indirectly asking Baby Jesus to become a priest. The second request was for a Sacred Heart of Jesus. This showed his early desire to love Our Lord and eventually led him to be called by the Holy Spirit as the Pope.  Christmas makes the mystery of all that Our Lord did for us come alive. When we speak about...