Skip to main content

WHY ARE CATHOLIC PRIESTS ALL MALE?

You are the salt of the earth. But if salt loses its taste, with what can it be seasoned? It is no longer good for anything but to be thrown out and trampled underfoot.” (Matthew 5:13)

Salt is something we cannot live without, and yet it’s something so small and seemingly insignificant. Salt can lose its taste if it contains impurities, so after the moisture evaporates, you are left with something that looks like salt but is not salt. Salt in the ocean water prevents earthquakes; salt in food production helps preserve our food for long periods and, most commonly, flavours our food. 

Sculpture of St. John Paul II in Rome, 13 May 2019

A priest is just like salt in its pure form. Nothing could take its taste away unless it were some artificial replacement from the onset. At ordination, the priest receives a permanent spiritual character marked on his soul that can never be removed. It is a grace conferred by Christ and cannot be repeated or given temporarily. 

A priest is not someone who decides tomorrow I’m going to be a preacher. In the Catholic Church, the priest is a minister of sacraments, such as Baptism, Confession, Holy Communion, Holy Orders and Anointing of the sick. In the Mass, the priest consecrates the bread and wine through the action of the Holy Spirit into the body and blood of Christ. This unique power is the grace of Christ working through the priest, and this great power demands great responsibility. 

Why cannot this grace work through a woman? What makes a man more special?

Feminists and LGBTQ+ persons, or whatever letter of the alphabet are in there now, need to hear this! Man and woman were created in the image and likeness of God, and the difference is embedded in the very thing that makes a man and woman biologically different. How do you explain to your two old that he is a boy and not a girl? When he bathes, he will want to ask what is this? It is your knee. What is that? It is your toes. What is this between my legs? It is your special gift of genitals, and for a boy, it’s a penis, and for a girl, she has a vagina and two breasts for nursing. Is it not odd we call every part of our body by its biological name, but for our greater parts we find alternate or diminutive names?! Or is it not crazy to say to your child if your toes want to be fingers, they can be fingers, just like if you want to be a different gender, you are free to be whatever you want?!

I will try to rephrase Christopher West, who unpacks this so eloquently. ‘Genitals’ are biologically referred to as our reproductive organs. In other words, it relates to our ability to ‘generate’ life (hence they are greater parts of our body). No wonder the first book of the Bible is called ‘Genesis’. Where does this life come from? It starts with the man who has ‘testicles’ which ‘testify’ he is a man that bears new life through the production of ‘semen’, a reproductive fluid. While male priests study and train to be priests in the ‘seminary’ derived from the root word ‘semen’, meaning ‘seed’. The world can make up its own rules, but it cannot break with natural law. A man gives life through his seed, and a woman receives life in the womb of her fertile garden; she germinates this seed and allows it to grow to one day give life to a child. A man will never bear and nurse new life as the seed giver, which makes man and woman complementary in their design. I repeat, men and women complement each other. They are not substitutes, nor is there a superior gender. 

A male is a priest because he bears the seed. A man gives life, and this is why Jesus Christ is both Man and God and why he chose twelve men as his apostles. Do you think God, who created us in his image and likeness, was sexist or thought that man was superior to a woman?! 

Therefore, a priest is a male because it is imprinted in his identity, not because the Church is old-fashioned or biased against women. Instead, for the same reason, a wife cannot produce semen and pass it to her husband to conceive a child. A man cannot naturally conceive and bear a child in a womb. Now, what if I go for some biological surgery? Then it is possible! Sure, doctors can work their immoral magic. Still, the fact that you have to go for some artificial surgery proves that it is not biologically possible and out of our design as male and female. 

The priest is Jesus Christ's representative on earth, and it makes sense that a man mirrors Our Lord. Does this make women less important in the Church? Women mirror the most perfect woman to have walked this earth, Our Lady, Mary the Mother of God. She beautifully expresses that God wills women to bear life in their blessed wombs. Jesus, Peter, Popes, priests and all men came into this world only because of a woman, so she is the nurturer of life in the Church. If it were not for another woman, Mary Magdalene as the first person and woman, to see the resurrected body of Our Lord, we would not have any Christian believers today. 

Priests, like salt, keep the foundations of the Catholic Church from buckling under the pressure of worldly earthquakes by standing up for the truth. Priests have preserved the life of the Church by not breaking the line of vested power from Jesus to Peter, to the Apostles, and to our present-day priests. The passing on of the sacrament of Holy Orders is what separates the priests from the pop-up pastors. Finally, through holding to tradition passed on down the generations through the guidance of the Holy Spirit, the priests have kept the body of the Church (the people) alive and full of flavour and vibrant with life. 


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

From the rising of the sun to its setting: we find the meaning of life

A few months ago we went away for the weekend to a little resort nestled in a ravine in Limpopo. It was the tail end of winter and so the chill of the early morning would bite, but this also meant watching the sun rise over the mountain, slowly pierce through the trees, stretching the first rays of the morning sun through the thick of the bush that had been in complete darkness through the night. Bela Bela, 07:17 - 26 July 2025 This made for prayer inspired by the treasure of nature, free of the distractions and hustle of city life. The sight of the sun sparked the words of the Mass in the common Eucharistic prayer, which quotes Psalm 113:3: "From the rising of the sun to its setting the name of the LORD is to be praised!" The sun rises and sets day after day without fail. As I sat there, I realised how small I was in the universe, a tiny insignificant dot at the tip of Africa in some random bush. However, at the same time, I felt so loved that in the immensity of the univers...

DEATH, A DOOR TO LIFE

I recently wrote about grandparents as humanities living memory and detailed how I had three grandparents still alive. A month later, my grandmother (Maria De Menezes) passed away, and six days later, my grandfather (Reginald Joel) passed on.  14 June 2021, God's Window Mpumalanga Death is a strange thing and most unnatural to human beings as it leaves us feeling empty, confused, and maybe afraid of what might await us on the other side. The most apparent question death makes us ponder is the question of why? Why must we die? Does God enjoy punishing us with the void the death of a loved one can leave in our hearts? The answer is a profound no!  Before sin entered the world, there was harmony between the body and soul. However, when the first man and woman chose to give in to the devil's temptation and succumbed to his luring. The nature of sin that entered the world broke this harmony. When sin enters the world by our free but misdirected choices, we allow corruption to weake...

DEAR BABY JESUS

It is already December; looking back, 2023 has flashed past in record time. The end of the year brings a big joy as we end the calendar year with the Advent season, which prepares us for the anticipation of the coming of Baby Jesus. This Christmas, I want to write about a letter that was found from Pope Benedict XVI's (the then Joseph Ratzinger) childhood.  @Pope_news, Twitter The young Pope referred to Our Lord as "Baby Jesus" and asked for two spiritual gifts in his letter and received them quite literally later on in his life. I had to search what this "green chasuble" is, and it is a priestly vestment worn to celebrate the Eucharist. In other words, he was indirectly asking Baby Jesus to become a priest. The second request was for a Sacred Heart of Jesus. This showed his early desire to love Our Lord and eventually led him to be called by the Holy Spirit as the Pope.  Christmas makes the mystery of all that Our Lord did for us come alive. When we speak about...

THE GREAT UNKNOWN!

Watching little children develop and grow is a fantastic thing to witness. Noah will be two years old in July and Leo one year old in August. Their milestones and progress help you realise how much we all develop from a tiny and utterly dependent infant into a toddler who wants to do everything themselves. Then to a child and before you know into a fully formed adult.  Noah & Leo, 27 June 2022 There are things babies and toddlers do not fully understand, and they need to go under the guidance of their parents. This can be a difficult phase for the toddler and parent as you both learn to understand each other and develop a new form of communication. At first, what we tell Noah or Leo may not make sense, but with time they begin to build awareness. For example, Noah loves blowing out candles but understands he should not touch the flame. He will say: "Wow, it's fire, eina," and for the non-South African reader, "eina" is an expression of pain or trouble.  In t...

ALL YOURS: I AM ALL YOURS, MARY!

The month of May is dedicated to celebrating motherhood. This is fitting considering the month of May also celebrates the Blessed Virgin Mary. A beautiful Marian custom this month is to make a pilgrimage to an image or statue of Our Lady.  Lowveld National Botanical Gardens, Mbombela (Nelspruit) As a family, Cassandra and I celebrated our third wedding anniversary on the 11th of May. We took a family break to the tranquil Mpumalanga with Noah and Leo. We decided to make our pilgrimage, which involves praying the rosary's glorious, joyful, and sorrowful mysteries on our trip to Hazyview.  The problem is that finding grottos, images, or a church open throughout the day is slim in South Africa. We took a chance to drive past a parish in Mbombela, but the doors were closed, and we found no image. The 400 km-plus journey can be tiring for little ones, and we decided to visit the Botanical Gardens for a leg stretch. Noah and Leo were able to play outdoors. On walking back to the car...